What Happens If Your 409A Valuation Is Inaccurate?

Risks, Penalties, and How to Avoid Them 

Startups are built on smart shortcuts. Founders move fast, bootstrap budgets, and look for cost-effective tools that help them grow. But when it comes to your 409A valuation, a “quick fix” can backfire—hard. 

From unexpected tax penalties to red flags in investor due diligence, a non-compliant valuation can cost your team time, money, and credibility. Here’s what’s at stake, and how to obtain a defensible 409A valuation. 

The Hidden Dangers of Cutting Corners on 409A Valuations 

Startup founders are resourceful by nature. With limited resources and time, it’s easy to see the appeal of a fast or free 409A valuation—especially those offered by platforms that use algorithm-based templates or internal teams instead of certified third-party appraisers. 

But here's the truth: cutting corners on your 409A valuation can create long-term risks that far outweigh the short-term savings. From IRS penalties to investor mistrust, a bad valuation can derail your startup’s growth. 

Understanding the Quick and Easy 409A Valuation Risks 

The IRS “Safe Harbor” Problem 

To qualify for safe harbor protection, a 409A valuation must be conducted by a qualified independent appraiser, such as one with ASA or CVA credentials. 

Using a provider without these credentials, or relying on an internal team or software-driven template, means your valuation may be easily challenged by the IRS, potentially exposing your company and employees to serious tax consequences. 

Possible Consequences for the Company and Its Employees 

If your valuation fails an audit: 

1. Employees may owe immediate taxes on their stock options 
2. A 20% penalty applies, plus interest 
3. It can lead to lawsuits, reputational damage, and difficulty hiring 

Investor Scrutiny During Due Diligence 

Any savvy VC will examine your 409A. If it’s rushed, outdated, or produced by a questionable provider, it raises governance concerns and could stall or kill a funding round.

 

The Anatomy of a Failed 409A: A Founder’s Cautionary Tale 

One early-stage startup opted for a low-cost provider promising a 24-hour turnaround. They received a generic report with no documentation of financials or milestones. 

Months later, during a Series A round, investors flagged the valuation as non-compliant. Due diligence stalled, employee options had to be re-issued, and the company spent tens of thousands redoing its valuation—plus legal and tax support. 

The lesson: shortcuts don’t scale. 

Preparing for Your First 409A: A Founder’s Checklist 

To ensure a smooth and defensible 409A valuation process, founders should consider gathering the following materials ahead of time: 

1. Cap table (updated and clean) 
2. Pitch deck and business plan 
3. Financial projections 
4. Key milestones (product, revenue, hiring) 
5. Recent financing documents 
6. Equity plan documents 
   

1. Will a certified appraiser conduct the valuation? 
2. Do they offer audit support? 
3. How do they evaluate qualitative factors like business model, risk, and team? 

Red Flags: How to Spot a Low-Quality 409A Valuation Provider 

Not all valuation services are created equal. Be wary of providers that offer: 

1. Suspiciously low prices 
2. 24-hour turnaround guarantees 
3. No credentials or audit support 
4. Vague methodologies or valuation logic 

Why a SAFE or Convertible Note Doesn’t Set Fair Market Value 

If your company recently raised money through a SAFE or convertible note, you might assume that the investment price can be used as your common stock FMV. It can’t. 

SAFEs and convertible notes are not priced equity. They represent either a future right to equity (SAFE) or convertible debt (note). Neither establishes FMV for common stock. 

That value must be independently assessed, ideally by a third-party appraiser, especially because common stock typically carries different rights and valuations than preferred shares. 

Choosing the Right Valuation Methodology for Your Growth Stage 

Not every valuation uses the same method. A professional provider will tailor the approach to your company’s stage: 

1. Market Approach: Based on comparable companies or transactions 
2. Income Approach: Projects future earnings and discounts them to present value 
3. Asset Approach: Weighs net assets, often used for very early-stage companies 

Read more about methodologies → 

The Professional Solution: A 409A Processed Through Fidelity Private Shares 

Fidelity Private Shares helps make 409A compliance easier, faster, and smarter. 

1. Vetted Experts: Connects you with qualified appraisers who deliver defensible, audit-ready reports 
2. Integrated Workflow: Pulls cap table and corporate data directly from your FPS platform 
3. Compliance Confidence: Meets IRS safe harbor standards and includes support in the event of an audit 
   

Help protect your team. Impress your investors. Avoid painful penalties. 
 
Schedule your 409A valuation today → 

Frequently Asked Questions About 409A Valuations 

How often should I get a new 409A valuation? 
At least once every 12 months, or whenever there’s a material event like new funding. 

What happens if my valuation is too high or too low? 
A high valuation makes stock options less appealing to employees, potentially limiting your hiring ability. A low valuation that lacks support can trigger IRS penalties and hurt your credibility during audits or funding rounds. 

Can my law firm or accounting firm perform my 409A valuation? 
Only if they have a qualified appraiser on staff. Most do not. 

Does a 409A valuation expire? 
Yes. Even if nothing changes, the IRS requires a new one every 12 months to retain safe harbor protection. 

409a valuations are conducted by a third party. 

1230615.1.0